Constructive dismissal is an important and complex concept within employment law. This guide is directed at Alberta employees with an aim to facilitate an understanding of constructive dismissal, employee rights, and steps involved in pursuing a claim
What Does Constructive Dismissal Mean?
Constructive dismissal occurs when an employer makes a unilateral and fundamental change to an employee’s employment contract such that the employee is effectively forced to leave their job. It can also arise when an employer engages in a course of conduct that demonstrates an intention no longer to be bound by the employment agreement.
In constructive dismissal cases, the employer does not terminate the employee, but rather the employee resigns. Although the employer does not formally terminate the employment relationship, the law may treat the employee’s resignation as a dismissal initiated by the employer.
Importantly, not every workplace disagreement or change in employment conditions amounts to constructive dismissal. The change or conduct must be substantial and fundamental to constitute a fundamental breach of the employment contract. Whether constructive dismissal has occurred depends on the specific circumstances, including the employee’s position, contractual rights, the nature of the changes and the overall employment relationship.
Constructive dismissal is also known as “disguised dismissal” or “quitting with cause”.
Examples of Constructive Dismissal in Alberta
Constructive dismissal can come in many forms. Common examples include:
- Significant decreases in salary
- Demotions
- Significant changes in job duties
- Toxic work environments
- Relocation
- Substantial reduction or change in hours
- Removing important benefits or pension entitlements
Legal Tests Used by Courts in Alberta
Alberta courts use a two-part legal framework for constructive dismissal, as set out by the Supreme Court in Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10. Constructive dismissal is established where:
- First, the employer imposed unilateral substantial changes that constitute a breach of the employment contract
- Second, a reasonable person in the employee’s position would have felt that the breach substantially altered a term of the employment contract
How Do You Prove Constructive Dismissal in Alberta?
In order to prove a constructive dismissal claim, an employee must gather evidence that supports their allegation and demonstrates that the employer makes significant changes to the employment terms and relationship.
Evidence that Alberta courts may consider includes:
- Written employment agreements
- Changes to employment conditions
- The employees acceptance or objection to changes
- Correspondence with the employer
- Performance reviews
- Witness statements
- Records of workplace conduct
- Past practices of the parties
If facing constructive dismissal, employees should document all changes to their job, keep records of correspondence and notes that address the changes, and gather witness statements to support their claim.
What Compensation Can You Receive for a Constructive Dismissal Claim in Alberta?
If an employee successfully establishes constructive dismissal, they may be entitled to compensation similar to severance pay they would have received following a wrongful dismissal.
The purpose of compensation is generally to put the employee in the financial position they would have been in had the employer provided reasonable notice of termination.
Depending on the circumstances, compensation may include:
- Pay in lieu of reasonable notice: Compensation for the notice period the employer should have provided. The amount depends on factors such as the employee’s age, length of service, position and availability of comparable employment. Ultimately, employees may be owed severance as they would receive if laid off or fired.
- Lost salary and wages: Compensation for regular earnings the employee would have received during the applicable notice period.
- Lost bonuses and commissions: Compensation for bonuses, commissions and other incentive payments that would have been earned during the reasonable notice period, subject to the applicable contractual terms.
- Lost employment benefits: Compensation for the value of health, dental, disability and other employment benefits that would have continued during the notice period.
- Pension and retirement contributions: Compensation for lost employer pension contributions and other applicable retirement benefits.
- Additional damages: In certain circumstances, employees may be entitled to aggravated damages where the employer’s conduct in the manner of dismissal was unfair or in bad faith and caused compensable harm. Damages for emotional distress may be awarded depending on the circumstances. Punitive damages may also be available in exceptional cases.
The amount of compensation depends on the facts of each case and the applicable employment agreement.
Employees should also be aware that they generally have a duty to mitigate their losses by making reasonable efforts to find comparable employment after dismissal.
Constructive Dismissal vs. Wrongful Dismissal: What Is the Difference?
Constructive dismissal and wrongful dismissal are related legal concepts, but they arise in different circumstances.
Wrongful dismissal occurs when an employer directly terminates an employee without providing the required notice or compensation in lieu of notice.
Constructive dismissal occurs when an employer does not formally terminate the employee, but the employer’s conduct effectively ended the employment relationship, leaving the employee with little reasonable choice but to resign.
The main difference is how the employment relationship ends.
For example, if an employer terminates an employee without providing adequate notice, the employee may have a wrongful dismissal claim.
Alternatively, if an employer significantly reduces an employee’s salary, removes their managerial responsibilities or substantially changes their position without consent, the employee may have grounds to resign and pursue a constructive dismissal claim.
In both situations, an employee may be entitled to reasonable notice or compensation in lieu of notice.
However, constructive dismissal claims require the employee to establish that the employer’s actions amounted to a fundamental breach of the employment contract. Simply resigning because of dissatisfaction with workplace conditions is not sufficient.
What to Do If You Believe You Have Been Constructively Dismissed
If you believe your employer unilaterally changed a fundamental term of your employment contract or has made your working environment intolerable, it is important to take appropriate steps and legal action protect your rights.
Consider the following:
- Review your employment agreement: Examine your written employment contract, including provisions relating to compensation, job responsibilities, working hours, benefits, termination and the employer’s ability to change employment conditions.
- Document the changes: Keep records of any reductions in salary, changes to responsibilities, demotions, workplace conduct, or other significant changes affecting your employment.
- Communicate your concerns in writing: Clearly explain your objections to the employer’s actions and promptly indicate that you do not agree to the unilateral changes. Keep copies of all communications.
- Avoid resigning prematurely: Resigning without first understanding your legal position can negatively affect your ability to establish constructive dismissal. Obtain legal advice before making a decision.
- Preserve relevant evidence: Retain employment agreements, emails, performance reviews, compensation records and other documents relevant to your claim. Be careful not to take confidential company information that you are not legally entitled to possess.
- Seek legal advice: An employment lawyer can assess whether the employer’s conduct amounts to constructive dismissal, identify potential compensation and advise you on the appropriate next steps.
Taking these steps can help protect your position and strengthen your ability to pursue compensation if constructive dismissal has occurred.
Facing Constructive Dismissal? Our Employment Lawyers can Help
Constructive dismissal claims can be complicated, particularly where an employer refuses to admit that it fundamentally changed the employment relationship or argues that the employee voluntarily resigned.
Our experienced employment lawyers help employees understand their legal rights, assess whether their employer’s conduct constitutes constructive dismissal and pursue appropriate compensation.
We can assist with reviewing employment agreements, evaluating changes to compensation and job responsibilities, gathering relevant evidence, negotiating termination pay and commencing legal proceedings where necessary.
Whether you are facing a significant salary reduction, demotion, removal of managerial responsibilities or an increasingly difficult workplace environment, obtaining legal advice early can make an important difference.
If you believe you have been constructively dismissed in Alberta, our employment and labour law lawyers can help you with your legal options. To find out whether you can claim constructive dismissal, contact our office today to book a consultation.



